Cambridge IELTS 15 · Academic · Test 4 · Advantages and disadvantages
Cambridge IELTS 15 Test 4 Writing Task 2: Sample Answer
The question, a plan, a Band 7.5 sample answer written by IELTS 9, why it scores that band on the 4 criteria, and the mistake most candidates make on this prompt.
Cambridge IELTS 15 Test 4 · Writing Task 2
In some cultures, children are often told that they can achieve anything if they try hard enough. What are the advantages and disadvantages of giving children this message?
Write at least 250 words. You should spend about 40 minutes on this task.
Try it yourself first
You learn more by writing your own answer before reading ours. Write it in 40 minutes and get a band for each criterion in about a minute.
Write and score my answer →Essay plan
- Introduction: message has benefits and risks
- Advantage: persistence and confidence
- Advantage: avoids passivity
- Disadvantages: false expectations, self-blame, conclusion
Band 7.5 sample answer (270 words)
Written by IELTS 9 to the Band 7.5 descriptors, not the book's own answer and not scored by an examiner. Use it for structure and language, then write your own.
Telling young people that effort alone can lead to any goal is a common practice in many societies. This message has genuine benefits, but it also carries risks that parents and teachers should not overlook.
The main advantage is the confidence and persistence it can foster. A child who believes that ability grows through practice is more likely to keep going after a failure, whether in mathematics or football. This attitude, often described as a growth mindset, encourages pupils to set ambitious targets and to treat mistakes as steps in learning rather than proof of inadequacy. Such optimism may also protect their mental wellbeing during the difficult years of adolescence.
Another benefit is that the message discourages passivity. If children are convinced that success is determined by luck or inherited talent, they may see little point in studying. Being told that effort genuinely matters gives them a sense of control over their own futures.
Nevertheless, the statement is not literally true, and presenting it as such creates disadvantages. A child of very short stature will not become a professional basketball player however hard he trains, and discovering this at eighteen can be crushing. Those who fail may also blame themselves entirely, overlooking factors such as family income, health or the quality of their schooling, which can lead to guilt and anxiety. In addition, unrealistic expectations may push pupils towards exhausting study schedules and the neglect of friendships and hobbies.
In conclusion, encouraging hard work is valuable, but it should be combined with honest guidance about personal strengths and the limits of circumstances. Children can then aim high without being misled.
Why this answer scores Band 7.5
- Task Response: Both advantages and disadvantages are covered with specific examples, and the conclusion offers a balanced judgement.
- Coherence and Cohesion: Short paragraphs are organised by advantage and disadvantage, and reference words such as 'such optimism' and 'the message' keep ideas connected.
- Lexical Resource: Expressions like 'growth mindset', 'sense of control' and 'exhausting study schedules' are accurate and not memorised.
- Grammatical Range and Accuracy: Conditionals, a concessive 'however hard he trains' and participial constructions show good control.
Useful vocabulary
Common mistake on this question
Write your own answer and get it scored
IELTS 9's AI examiner scores your essay on Task Response, Coherence and Cohesion, Lexical Resource, and Grammatical Range and Accuracy, with corrections and an improved version. Your first 2 essay evaluations are free.
Score my essay →More from Cambridge IELTS 15
Test 1 · Two-part direct question
In some countries, owning a home rather than renting one is very important for people. Why might this be the case? Do you think this is a positive or negative situation?
Test 2 · Opinion essay
In the future, nobody will buy printed newspapers or books because they will be able to read everything they want online without paying. To what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
Test 3 · Discuss both views
Some people say that advertising is extremely successful at persuading us to buy things. Other people think that advertising is so common that we no longer pay attention to it. Discuss both these views and give your own opinion.